The conversation around the concept of determinism isn't whether it's true or not, that's boring. Of course it's true. That's a fact whether you you try to argue it neurologically or through physics. The conversation should be centered around two questions. One: If free will does not exist, then does quality exist? And two: Does it even matter if we are free or not at the end of the day? The second question being the easiest of of the two to answer, so we will begin with that. If I find two people who are the opposite one another. The first being someone who is ambitious, out going and strives to achieve the goals they set. The second is someone who is terribly depressed, makes little effort and has no real goals. If I were to tell each of them that free will does not exist and go into great detail as to why, to ensure that each understood, what do you think would happen? I have no doubt that the ambitious person, even if interested in the concept, will not allow it to affect their life in any way. They will most likely even just brush it off and continue about their day. However if I was to do the same with the other person, they may use it as reason as to why their life is the way it is. They may incorporate it into their thinking and wonder 'why bother?' when thinking about their ambitions. So in the end the determinists and the libertarians and the compatibilists can argue over the various points of free will, but at the end of the day to the average person, it doesn't matter. And as I have mentioned before, makes for a very boring discussion.
It is only when we incorporate the idea of quality that a more worthwhile discussion can be had. If quality does not exist within the universe natrually and only comes into being through intelligent life. And if free will does not exist, meaning that living organisms are just another part of the universe no different than the burning sun or the ebbing ocean, then can quality exist? That rock formation no matter how beautiful or majestic has no essence of quality, the formation just happened to end up that way due to time, erosion and other natrual forces. Nothing of quality went into creating it and as a result it cannot embody quality. However if we take a finely made dining table made by a craftsman. Then something that had no quality before, in this case wood, is infused with the craftsman skill, care and desire to create something that can now be said to have quality. But can it not be said that the craftsmans desire to create something only imbues the essence of quality if it is done of free will? Otherwise what is the difference between the craftsman creating a table and erosion creating a rock formation? The bones, muscles and brain that allow the craftsman to act are nothing more than the organic equivalent of the cogs and screws that cause a hand of clock to tick.
So if we see now that if free will does not exist, than neither can quality. This reasoning may not give an answer to the question "What is the purpose of life in the universe?". But upon removing it we can either discuss other possible options or accept that there really is no difference between us and the ticking clock.
No comments:
Post a Comment